Back to all reviewers

Verify authentication logic

appwrite/appwrite
Based on 1 comments
Javascript

Ensure authentication validation logic follows expected semantics and intuitive implementation. Authentication checks should correctly interpret the presence or absence of security tokens, with clear and accurate logging that reflects the actual security state.

Security Javascript

Reviewer Prompt

Ensure authentication validation logic follows expected semantics and intuitive implementation. Authentication checks should correctly interpret the presence or absence of security tokens, with clear and accurate logging that reflects the actual security state.

When implementing JWT or other token-based authentication:

  • Presence of valid tokens should indicate authenticated/valid states
  • Absence of tokens should indicate unauthenticated/invalid states
  • Log messages and condition branches should match these intuitive expectations

Example:

// Correct implementation
if (context.req.headers['x-appwrite-user-jwt']) {
  context.log('jwt-is-valid');
  // Proceed with authenticated operations
} else {
  context.log('jwt-is-invalid');
  // Handle unauthenticated state
}

This prevents security vulnerabilities that could arise from misinterpreting authentication states and ensures proper access control throughout the application.

1
Comments Analyzed
Javascript
Primary Language
Security
Category

Source Discussions