Back to all reviewers

Vet security-critical dependencies

influxdata/influxdb
Based on 1 comments
Toml

When introducing new dependencies, especially those handling sensitive operations like language interpreters, perform comprehensive security due diligence before adoption. Evaluate each dependency against these security criteria:

Security Toml

Reviewer Prompt

When introducing new dependencies, especially those handling sensitive operations like language interpreters, perform comprehensive security due diligence before adoption. Evaluate each dependency against these security criteria:

  1. Maintenance health: Check for active development, large user base, and responsive contributors.
  2. Security track record: Review CVE history to confirm security issues are promptly addressed.
  3. Security integration: Verify integration with vulnerability tracking systems like GitHub advisories.
  4. Contingency planning: Document alternatives if the dependency becomes unmaintained.

For critical dependencies, document your findings in a security assessment that includes:

  • Vulnerability history analysis
  • Update frequency and responsiveness
  • Embedded component maintenance strategy (if applicable)
  • Security monitoring approach

Example from assessment:

// Security-vetted dependency
[dependencies.pyo3]
version = "0.23.3"  // Includes fix for CVE-2024-9979

Always maintain awareness of dependency status. When a critical dependency becomes unmaintained (as happened with PyOxidizer), promptly implement your contingency plan by switching to maintained alternatives (like using pyo3 with python-build-standalone).

1
Comments Analyzed
Toml
Primary Language
Security
Category

Source Discussions