Back to all reviewers

condition-based network synchronization

apache/kafka
Based on 2 comments
Other

When waiting for network state propagation or distributed system synchronization, avoid using fixed sleep times and instead implement condition-based waiting that verifies the actual desired state. Fixed delays are unreliable in network environments due to variable latency and don't guarantee the expected state has been reached.

Networking Other

Reviewer Prompt

When waiting for network state propagation or distributed system synchronization, avoid using fixed sleep times and instead implement condition-based waiting that verifies the actual desired state. Fixed delays are unreliable in network environments due to variable latency and don’t guarantee the expected state has been reached.

Instead of using arbitrary sleep durations:

def sleepMillisToPropagateMetadata(durationMs: Long, partition: TopicPartition): Unit = {
  Thread.sleep(durationMs)  // Unreliable - doesn't verify actual state
}

Implement condition-based waiting that polls for the actual desired network state:

def waitForMetadataPropagation(brokers: Seq[Broker], partition: TopicPartition): Unit = {
  TestUtils.waitUntilTrue(() => {
    brokers.forall(broker => 
      getPartitionLeader(broker, partition) == expectedLeader
    )
  }, "Metadata propagation across all brokers")
}

This approach ensures reliable synchronization by verifying that all network nodes have reached the expected state, rather than assuming a fixed time duration is sufficient for network propagation.

2
Comments Analyzed
Other
Primary Language
Networking
Category

Source Discussions