Back to all reviewers

Document precise security requirements

apache/kafka
Based on 2 comments
Html

Security documentation must specify exact permission requirements with clear scope and timing details. Vague or outdated security requirements can lead to insufficient ACL configurations, creating security gaps or deployment failures.

Security Html

Reviewer Prompt

Security documentation must specify exact permission requirements with clear scope and timing details. Vague or outdated security requirements can lead to insufficient ACL configurations, creating security gaps or deployment failures.

When documenting security permissions:

  • Specify the exact operations required (e.g., DESCRIBE, READ, CREATE)
  • Clearly define the resource scope (e.g., “all topics in the application’s topology” vs “topics included in the message”)
  • Include timing context when permissions are needed (e.g., “when first joining”)
  • Keep documentation synchronized with implementation changes

Example of imprecise vs precise documentation:

// Imprecise - could lead to missing permissions
Required for all topics included in the message

// Precise - clear scope and timing
Required for all topics used in the application's topology, when first joining

Regularly review security documentation against actual implementation requirements to ensure accuracy and completeness.

2
Comments Analyzed
Html
Primary Language
Security
Category

Source Discussions