Back to all reviewers

Lock responsibly, always

maplibre/maplibre-native
Based on 2 comments
Java

Ensure proper management of locks and concurrent resources throughout their lifecycle. When implementing concurrency: 1. Encapsulate locking/unlocking in appropriate methods rather than duplicating code

Concurrency Java

Reviewer Prompt

Ensure proper management of locks and concurrent resources throughout their lifecycle. When implementing concurrency:

  1. Encapsulate locking/unlocking in appropriate methods rather than duplicating code
  2. Be mindful of which threads acquire locks and consider thread-safety implications
  3. Implement proper timeout handling for waiting on concurrent operations
  4. Account for race conditions during cleanup of concurrent resources

Example:

// Good: Locks encapsulated in methods where they're used
public String getResourcesCachePath() {
    resourcesCachePathLoaderLock.lock();
    try {
        // critical section operations
        return resourcesCachePath;
    } finally {
        resourcesCachePathLoaderLock.unlock();
    }
}

// For waiting on task queues, implement timeouts and handle potential race conditions
public int waitForEmpty(long timeoutMillis) {
    // Implementation that respects timeout and returns remaining tasks
    // without resetting timeout if new tasks are added
}

Avoid duplicating locking code across methods, and ensure locks are released in finally blocks to prevent deadlocks. When implementing methods that wait for concurrent operations to complete, provide sensible timeout options and consider the implications of race conditions.

2
Comments Analyzed
Java
Primary Language
Concurrency
Category

Source Discussions