Back to all reviewers

validate algorithmic edge cases

microsoft/playwright
Based on 4 comments
TypeScript

Algorithms must be thoroughly tested at boundary conditions and edge cases to prevent subtle bugs. Pay special attention to off-by-1 errors in mathematical calculations, empty collections, and boundary values that might cause unexpected behavior.

Algorithms TypeScript

Reviewer Prompt

Algorithms must be thoroughly tested at boundary conditions and edge cases to prevent subtle bugs. Pay special attention to off-by-1 errors in mathematical calculations, empty collections, and boundary values that might cause unexpected behavior.

Common edge cases to validate:

  • Mathematical boundaries (e.g., Math.log10(10) edge case)
  • Empty or single-element collections
  • Maximum/minimum values in ranges
  • Conditional logic branches with complex state

Example from the codebase:

// Problematic - fails for totalTestCount === 10
const indexLength = Math.ceil(Math.log10(this.totalTestCount));

// Correct - handles the edge case properly  
const indexLength = Math.ceil(Math.log10(this.totalTestCount + 1));

When implementing algorithms, create test cases that specifically target these boundary conditions. Consider reusing existing, well-tested algorithmic logic rather than reimplementing similar functionality, as proven algorithms are less likely to contain edge case bugs.

4
Comments Analyzed
TypeScript
Primary Language
Algorithms
Category

Source Discussions