Back to all reviewers

Explicit configuration precedence

pola-rs/polars
Based on 5 comments
Python

Implement a clear configuration resolution chain that follows a consistent precedence pattern: explicit parameters first, then environment variables, then default values. This ensures predictable behavior and proper respect for user-provided settings at different levels.

Configurations Python

Reviewer Prompt

Implement a clear configuration resolution chain that follows a consistent precedence pattern: explicit parameters first, then environment variables, then default values. This ensures predictable behavior and proper respect for user-provided settings at different levels.

When a parameter can be configured through multiple means (function parameters, environment variables, config files), default it to None in function signatures and explicitly handle the resolution sequence in your code:

def process_data(engine=None):
    # Check explicit parameter first
    if engine is None:
        # Then check environment variable
        engine = get_engine_from_environment()
        if engine is None:
            # Finally use the default value
            engine = "cpu"

This approach offers several benefits:

  • Users can understand and predict which configuration source takes precedence
  • Function calls without explicit parameters will respect environment configurations
  • You can track the source of a configuration setting for better error messages
  • The code clearly documents the fallback behavior
  • It becomes easier to add new configuration sources without breaking existing code

When documenting these parameters, clearly communicate the precedence chain so users understand how their configurations will be applied.

5
Comments Analyzed
Python
Primary Language
Configurations
Category

Source Discussions