Back to all reviewers

ensure mathematical correctness

prometheus/prometheus
Based on 4 comments
Other

When implementing or testing algorithms, ensure mathematical relationships and constraints are maintained throughout the computation. Test data should have plausible values that reflect real-world mathematical relationships, and algorithmic edge cases should be carefully handled to prevent mathematical inconsistencies.

Algorithms Other

Reviewer Prompt

When implementing or testing algorithms, ensure mathematical relationships and constraints are maintained throughout the computation. Test data should have plausible values that reflect real-world mathematical relationships, and algorithmic edge cases should be carefully handled to prevent mathematical inconsistencies.

Key areas to focus on:

  1. Test data consistency: Ensure test values have plausible mathematical relationships. For example, if testing histogram data, the sum field should reflect realistic values based on bucket distributions rather than arbitrary numbers.

  2. Interpolation and extrapolation boundaries: When algorithms involve interpolation or extrapolation (like counter increases), carefully choose test intervals and handle edge cases where extrapolation might produce invalid results (e.g., negative values for counters).

  3. Numerical precision awareness: Be mindful of floating-point precision issues, especially in aggregation algorithms. Direct calculations may be more precise than incremental approaches for certain operations.

Example from histogram testing:

# Bad: Arbitrary sum value that doesn't match bucket distribution
h_test 

# Good: Sum value that reflects realistic bucket distribution  
h_test 

This approach helps ensure algorithms behave correctly under various mathematical conditions and produce results that maintain expected mathematical properties.

4
Comments Analyzed
Other
Primary Language
Algorithms
Category

Source Discussions