Back to all reviewers

Document component behavior comprehensively

astral-sh/ruff
Based on 5 comments
Rust

Documentation should clearly explain the purpose, behavior, and relationships between code components using accessible terminology. This helps other developers understand the code without needing to dig into implementations.

Documentation Rust

Reviewer Prompt

Documentation should clearly explain the purpose, behavior, and relationships between code components using accessible terminology. This helps other developers understand the code without needing to dig into implementations.

Key practices:

  1. Document relationships between components (classes, traits, modules) to show how they interact
  2. Explain the purpose of fields in data structures and enums
  3. Document function behavior limitations, edge cases, and potential failure modes
  4. Use terminology accessible to users without deep implementation knowledge

Example of improved documentation:

/// A tuple length specification.
#[derive(Clone, Copy, Debug, Eq, PartialEq)]
pub(crate) enum TupleLength {
    /// A tuple with exactly `n` elements
    Fixed(usize),
    /// A variable-length tuple with `prefix_len` required elements at the start
    /// and `suffix_len` required elements at the end
    Variable(usize, usize),
}

/// Return true if this is a type that is always fully static (has no dynamic part; 
/// represents a single set of possible values.)
///
/// Note: This function may have false negatives (return false for some static types),
/// but should not have false positives (will never return true for non-static types).
fn is_fully_static(&self) -> bool {
    // implementation...
}

When documenting methods that may panic or fail under certain conditions, clearly state these conditions:

/// Get the AST node for this class.
/// 
/// # Panics
/// Panics if the provided module belongs to a different file than this class.
fn node<'ast>(self, db: &'db dyn Db, module: &'ast ParsedModuleRef) -> &'ast ast::StmtClassDef {
    // implementation...
}

Comprehensive documentation reduces the learning curve for new contributors and helps prevent bugs caused by misunderstandings about component behavior.

5
Comments Analyzed
Rust
Primary Language
Documentation
Category

Source Discussions