Back to all reviewers

Meaningful test design

getsentry/sentry
Based on 2 comments
TypeScript

Write tests that focus on unique edge cases and avoid redundancy. When designing test suites: 1. Consolidate similar test cases that don't provide additional coverage

Testing TypeScript

Reviewer Prompt

Write tests that focus on unique edge cases and avoid redundancy. When designing test suites:

  1. Consolidate similar test cases that don’t provide additional coverage
  2. Focus on meaningful edge cases that actually test different code paths
  3. Structure test fixtures to be reusable and parameterizable

Instead of redundant tests:

it('should return empty array for empty object input', () => {
  expect(uniq({})).toStrictEqual([]);
});

it('should return empty array for object with properties', () => {
  expect(uniq({key: 'value'})).toStrictEqual([]);
});

Write a more meaningful test:

it('should return empty array for array-like objects that are not arrays', () => {
  const arrayLike = {0: 'a', 1: 'b', length: 2};
  expect(uniq(arrayLike as any)).toStrictEqual([]);
});

For test fixtures, place them in dedicated directories (e.g., tests/js/fixtures/) and design them to accept parameters for customization:

// tests/js/fixtures/tabularColumn.ts
export const TabularColumnFixture = (params: Partial<TabularColumn> = {}): TabularColumn => ({
  key: 'default-key',
  name: 'Default Name',
  type: 'string',
  ...params,
});

This approach improves test maintainability and ensures your test suite provides meaningful coverage without unnecessary bloat.

2
Comments Analyzed
TypeScript
Primary Language
Testing
Category

Source Discussions