Back to all reviewers

AI dependency justification

sgl-project/sglang
Based on 2 comments
Toml

When modifying AI library dependencies, always provide clear justification for version choices, especially when using non-standard sources like git commits or release candidates. This is critical for AI projects where library compatibility and stability directly impact model performance and inference reliability.

AI Toml

Reviewer Prompt

When modifying AI library dependencies, always provide clear justification for version choices, especially when using non-standard sources like git commits or release candidates. This is critical for AI projects where library compatibility and stability directly impact model performance and inference reliability.

For standard version updates, explain the motivation (bug fixes, new features, compatibility requirements). For non-standard sources like git commits, document:

  • The specific issue being resolved
  • Why the official release is insufficient
  • Plans for migrating back to official releases

Example of good justification:

# Using git commit due to bug in official v4.49.0 that affects vision models
"transformers @ git+https://github.com/huggingface/transformers.git@84f0186",
# TODO: Migrate back to official release when v4.49.1+ is available

This practice prevents confusion during code reviews, helps with dependency auditing, and ensures the team understands the rationale behind critical AI library choices that could affect model behavior or performance.

2
Comments Analyzed
Toml
Primary Language
AI
Category

Source Discussions