Back to all reviewers

async cleanup safety

sveltejs/svelte
Based on 3 comments
JavaScript

Ensure async operations include proper safety checks to prevent race conditions, memory leaks, and inconsistent state. This includes equality checks before updates, destruction status verification, and proper cleanup mechanisms.

Concurrency JavaScript

Reviewer Prompt

Ensure async operations include proper safety checks to prevent race conditions, memory leaks, and inconsistent state. This includes equality checks before updates, destruction status verification, and proper cleanup mechanisms.

Key safety patterns to implement:

  • Equality checks: Always verify !source.equals(value) before applying updates in async contexts to prevent unnecessary side effects
  • Destruction checks: Verify effects haven’t been destroyed before adding dependencies: var destroyed = active_effect !== null && (active_effect.f & DESTROYED) !== 0
  • Memory leak prevention: Use WeakRef or similar patterns for long-lived async objects that reference reactions

Example of unsafe vs safe async operation:

// Unsafe - missing equality check
export function simple_set(source, value) {
  source.v = value;
  source.o?.onchange?.(); // fires even when value unchanged
}

// Safe - includes equality check
export function set(source, value) {
  if (!source.equals(value)) {
    source.v = value;
    source.o?.onchange?.();
  }
}

The “simple” optimization often becomes a “bug magnet” by removing essential safety checks that prevent race conditions in concurrent scenarios.

3
Comments Analyzed
JavaScript
Primary Language
Concurrency
Category

Source Discussions