Back to all reviewers

Justify configuration changes

sveltejs/svelte
Based on 2 comments
Json

When making configuration changes, especially dependency upgrades, provide clear justification for why the change is necessary rather than simply updating to the latest version. Explain the specific benefits, required features, or problems being solved.

Configurations Json

Reviewer Prompt

When making configuration changes, especially dependency upgrades, provide clear justification for why the change is necessary rather than simply updating to the latest version. Explain the specific benefits, required features, or problems being solved.

For dependency upgrades, identify the minimum version needed and the specific features that require the upgrade. Consider the impact on related tools and dependencies that may also need updating.

Example from a TypeScript upgrade discussion:

// Instead of just upgrading to latest
"typescript": "^4.0.0"

// Provide justification in PR description:
// "TypeScript 3.7+ needed for optional chaining feature used in new code.
// Updated to 3.9.7 (minimum required) rather than 4.0.0 to minimize compatibility risks.
// Also updated sucrase dependency which requires compatible TypeScript version."

This approach helps reviewers understand the necessity of changes and prevents unnecessary upgrades that could introduce instability or compatibility issues.

2
Comments Analyzed
Json
Primary Language
Configurations
Category

Source Discussions