Back to all reviewers

Analyze algorithm tradeoffs

temporalio/temporal
Based on 2 comments
Other

When implementing functionality that involves multiple possible algorithmic approaches, explicitly analyze the complexity tradeoffs between alternatives before making a decision. Consider factors such as:

Algorithms Other

Reviewer Prompt

When implementing functionality that involves multiple possible algorithmic approaches, explicitly analyze the complexity tradeoffs between alternatives before making a decision. Consider factors such as:

  1. Time and space complexity for different operations
  2. Memory allocation patterns and efficiency
  3. Impact on dependent systems (e.g., replication in distributed systems)
  4. Data representation efficiency for different access patterns

Document your reasoning to make the decision process clear to reviewers and future maintainers.

Example:

// Approach chosen: Store component status directly in the task
// Considered alternatives:
// 1. Maintain timestamp list in mutable state
//    Pros: No need for versioned_transition_offset field
//    Cons: More complex updates when nodes/tasks are removed
//          Requires checking entire tree or maintaining reference counts
//          Additional write operations at task processing time
// 2. Current approach with direct status field
//    Pros: Simpler update logic
//          versioned_transition_offset provides additional benefits
//          for referencing specific component tasks
//    Cons: Requires carrying over status during replication
2
Comments Analyzed
Other
Primary Language
Algorithms
Category

Source Discussions