Back to all reviewers

Consistent authentication patterns

astral-sh/uv
Based on 4 comments
Markdown

Design API authentication mechanisms with consistent patterns, clear documentation, and helpful error messages. When implementing authentication: 1. **Document authentication requirements explicitly**:

API Markdown

Reviewer Prompt

Design API authentication mechanisms with consistent patterns, clear documentation, and helpful error messages. When implementing authentication:

  1. Document authentication requirements explicitly:
    • Specify expected username/token formats and any special cases
    • Explain how authentication failures are handled
  2. Design credentials lookup intelligently:
    # Prefer using the base index URL for credential lookup
    # Instead of:
    credentials = keyring.get_credential(package_url, None)
       
    # Use:
    credentials = keyring.get_credential(index_url, None)
    
  3. Provide clear error messages for authentication failures:
    If you use `--token "$JFROG_TOKEN"` with JFrog, you will receive a 
    401 Unauthorized error as JFrog requires an empty username but 
    uv passes `__token__` as the username when `--token` is used.
    
  4. Consider consistency across similar operations:
    • Use the same authentication patterns for related endpoints
    • Document when different operations require different authentication formats
    • Be explicit about URL formatting requirements (e.g., trailing slashes)
  5. Test authentication edge cases:
    • Verify behavior with missing credentials
    • Test various token formats
    • Confirm proper handling of authentication failures
4
Comments Analyzed
Markdown
Primary Language
API
Category

Source Discussions