Back to all reviewers

Optimize data structures

vitessio/vitess
Based on 6 comments
Go

Choose and implement data structures with careful consideration of algorithmic complexity, memory usage, and Go's specific performance characteristics. Pay attention to:

Algorithms Go

Reviewer Prompt

Choose and implement data structures with careful consideration of algorithmic complexity, memory usage, and Go’s specific performance characteristics. Pay attention to:

  1. Placement of operations in code flow: Consider when and where operations are performed, especially in loops or before early returns.
// Be careful with operations inside loops
func (set Mysql56GTIDSet) AddGTIDInPlace(gtid GTID) GTIDSet {
    // ...
    for _, iv := range intervals {
        // ... processing logic ...
        
        // Incorrect: Updating data structure in every loop iteration
        set[gtid56.Server] = newIntervals
    }
    // Correct: Update once after loop completes (when appropriate)
    set[gtid56.Server] = newIntervals
}

However, be mindful of early returns that might skip operations:

// Early returns may require updates within the loop
for _, iv := range intervals {
    if condition {
        // Update needed here if we might return
        set[gtid56.Server] = newIntervals
        return set
    }
}
  1. Efficient implementation choices: Choose implementations that avoid unnecessary overhead:
    • Prefer direct binary operations over reflection-based alternatives like binary.Write
    • Consider specialized data structures for specific use cases (e.g., Disjoint Set Union for transitive closures)
    • Order type assertions from most specific to most general to avoid unnecessary checks
  2. Accurate metrics and counts: Ensure methods that report on data structure state (like length or size) accurately reflect the true state:
    • Avoid double-counting elements in queue implementations
    • Be precise about what your metrics represent (buffer capacity vs. element count)

By thoughtfully designing and implementing your data structures, you can significantly improve both performance and maintainability of your code.

6
Comments Analyzed
Go
Primary Language
Algorithms
Category

Source Discussions