Awesome Reviewers

Verification · Feedback and evaluation · Reviewer optimization

Instruction updates from feedback

Update reviewer instructions from accepted and rejected findings.

How to build it

  1. Record each accepted and rejected finding with the instruction it came from.
  2. Feed rejected findings back as critique of the instruction text.
  3. Review each instruction change like a code change before merge.

Signals in a repository

  • A feedback log that stores accepted and rejected findings per instruction.
  • Pull requests that edit reviewer instruction files with a feedback reference.
  • Instruction files with a changelog or version history.

In practice

No scanned repository runs a tool for this check. The steps above are the only guidance.