Awesome Reviewers

Verification · Finding validation · External contract verification

Proof grading

Grade as definitive (spec or exhaustive enum), illustrative (an example) or unresolved.

How to build it

  1. Mark a finding definitive when it cites the spec clause or an exhaustive list of cases.
  2. Mark a finding illustrative when it rests only on an example input.
  3. Mark a finding unresolved when no spec or source for the claim can be found.

Signals in a repository

  • Finding records with a proof field holding definitive, illustrative or unresolved.
  • Review comments that quote a spec section or list the cases they checked.

In practice

No scanned repository runs a tool for this check. The steps above are the only guidance.