Awesome Reviewers

Verification · Finding validation · Evidence-backed verification

Proof requirement

Drop findings that cite no line, input or behaviour.

How to build it

  1. Reject any finding that does not name a file and line.
  2. Require each finding to state the input or sequence that triggers the behaviour.
  3. Drop findings whose claim cannot be tied to code in the diff.

Signals in a repository

  • Review tool templates or schemas that require a line reference and a triggering input.
  • Bot comments that give a file, line and triggering input for each finding.

In practice

No scanned repository runs a tool for this check. The steps above are the only guidance.