Awesome Reviewers

Verification · Feedback and evaluation · Reviewer evaluation

Side-by-side comparison

Run two reviewer versions on the same set and compare.

How to build it

  1. Run two reviewer versions on the same set of labelled changes.
  2. Store each version's findings side by side in one results file.
  3. Merge a reviewer change only when the new version is not worse on recall or precision.

Signals in a repository

  • A comparison config that names two reviewer versions.
  • A results report that shows both versions for each case.
  • A pull request template item that asks for a comparison run on reviewer changes.

In practice

No scanned repository runs a tool for this check. The steps above are the only guidance.